Mark Brown's column March 2
(reprinted from Sun-Times without permission ... apologies to Mark Brown)
Ald. James Cappleman (46th) informed the
Salvation Army on Friday that it is no longer welcome to feed the poor
in Uptown from its homeless outreach trucks.
Cappleman gave the social service agency one
month to find a new North Side location — outside his ward — before
ceasing operations, said Capt. Nancy Powers, who oversees the Salvation
Army’s homeless program in Chicago.
“He decided he felt the unit was pulling homeless into the area, and he does not want us to feed them,” Powers told me. Powers said the Salvation Army will depart willingly.
“We don’t want to be where we’re not wanted,” she said. But Powers expressed concern for those living in
the neighborhood who rely on the truck for a daily hot meal — which the
agency uses as a lure to connect the homeless with its social workers.
This ought to clear up any lingering doubts as to
Cappleman’s motivation in seeking to close the Wilson Men’s Hotel, one
of the city’s last two cubicle hotels, the subject of several recent
columns.
He’s obviously decided to rid the 46th Ward of
unsightly poor people — with a not entirely dissimilar approach to the
one he has employed to disappear pigeons.
When I wrote about the pigeon situation (remember
the Indiana farmer and his “pigeon shoots,”) I thought Cappleman was
just a little aggressive. Now I’m starting to think he’s downright
dangerous.
For his part, Cappleman told me via email Friday:
“We continue to be concerned about the plight of the homeless,
especially during these cold winter months. As the Salvation Army mobile
outreach unit tapers off, we are working with other social service
agencies to try a new approach that we believe will be more effective
with empowering these individuals experiencing homelessness to get out
of the cycle of homelessness.”
Naturally, Cappleman did not identify these
“other social service agencies” or this “new approach.” Nor did he give a
direct answer to my questions about whether he blames the feeding
program for bringing the homeless into his ward — or what he thinks is
wrong with feeding them.
“There’s always the question of the chicken or
the egg,” acknowledged Powers, who went out of her way to avoid casting
this as a fight with Cappleman.
I’m well aware of the conundrum surrounding
services to the poor. The agencies who do a good job of providing those
services try to locate in the areas where they see the most need, but
others argue the availability of the service then attracts more who need
it.
That has long been a bone of contention in
Uptown, where a decades-old pocket of poverty has given rise to some of
the city’s most well-established social service agencies, which in turn
are seen by some residents as an obstacle to neighborhood
revitalization.
Powers said the Salvation Army began bringing its
mobile outreach unit to Uptown at the request of Cappleman’s
predecessor, Ald. Helen Shiller, soon after its creation in 2009.
While Salvation Army personnel serve up bowls of
hot soup, two social workers specializing in substance abuse and mental
health mingle with the crowd and try to forge relationships with the
homeless to identify those who are ready to get off the street.
A “chaser van” goes along to immediately transport anyone who is ready to enter rehab or go to the hospital.
Operating from a location at Wilson and Marine,
the unit feeds 100 people on average at midday Monday through Friday,
Powers said. In recent years, most of those lining up for food have been
residents of nearby single room occupancy buildings who can’t afford to
eat, she said.
Cappleman informed the Salvation Army it was welcome to continue to provide the social workers, but not to feed anybody.
Powers said the program won’t work that way.
“[The food] is our calling card to get people to come to us,” she explained.
The mobile outreach unit also operates daily from
four other locations in the city. In addition, the Salvation Army
operates mobile feeding trucks that go to 22 other sites — but with no
homeless support. The Uptown location is the only North Side site.
Powers said she has been in discussions with
Cappleman about his concerns for several months, but that he delivered
his final decision in a meeting Friday, word of which leaked out to me.
The Salvation Army will ask other Lakefront aldermen to provide a location to fill the void.
As a “licensed clinical social worker,”
Cappleman claims special insights into how to deal with the problems of
poor people. I guess that’s why he treats them like pigeons.
Posts
